JVC Picsio GC-FM1 Camcorder Review

by Kaitlyn Chantry and Jeremy Stamas
Published on Oct 27, 2009 10:01 PM

 
Intro Product Tour
Colour & Noise Performance
Motion & Sharpness Performance
Low Light Performance Compression & Media
Manual Controls Still Features
Handling & Use Playback & Connectivity
Audio & Other Features Flip UltraHD Comparison
Sony MHS-PM1 Comparison Kodak Zx1 Comparison
Conclusion Photo Gallery
Specs and Ratings


Colour & Noise Performance Summary
The JVC GC-FM1• Very good colour accuracy in bright light—as good as JVC's regular consumer camcorders (like the GZ-HD300 or the GZ-X900).
• Saturation levels were also good and colours were strong and vibrant.
• Noise levels were on the high side, but they weren't the worst we've ever seen.
previous Product Tour (Page 3 of 17) Motion & Sharpness Performance next

 

Colour (10.94)


The JVC GC-FM1 surprised us with its excellent colour accuracy in bright light (and low light too, for that matter). The camcorder registered a colour error of 3.2 with a saturation level of 86.4%. These are better numbers than most budget flash camcorders are capable of. In fact, the GC-FM1's colour error is very similar to what most of JVC's regular consumer camcorders earned in this test. This is a testament to JVC's ability to render accurate and strong colours in all of its models. (More on how we test colour.)

Colour Accuracy Performance
The JVC GC-FM1 at 3000 lux auto The JVC GC-FM1 color error chart
Colour Test Chart (above), Colour Error Map (right)
The JVC GC-FM1 produced a colour error of 3.2 and a saturation level of 86.4% in our bright light colour testing. (The map on the right is a diagram of the colour error. The length and direction of each line indicates how the camcorder processed each particular colour.)

The Error Map above shows that the GC-FM1 was most accurate rendering reds, blues and certain browns, while green tones gave the camcorder the most trouble. The GC-FM1 has no colour mode options, so there is no way to tweak the saturation or adjust the colours on the camcorder. Below is a sample image from our colour testing.

JVC GC-FM1 Colour Sample
The JVC GC-FM1 in auto mode The JVC GC-FM1 in auto mode, 100% crop
Auto 100% Crop

Many ultra-compact camcorders have difficulty rendering an accurate white balance during our colour testing. The Kodak Zx1 was the worst culprit and the Flip UltraHD also showed a slight yellow hue. The JVC GC-FM1, however, seems to handle auto white balance quite well. Its bright light image is evenly-toned with accurate colours. The Sony MHS-PM1 also fared well with white balance, but colours were less saturated and less accurate than those rendered by the Picsio.

JVC GC-FM1 Colour Comparisons
JVC GC-FM1 Flip UltraHD
Sony MHS-PM1 Kodak Zx1

Since there is no real way to define "what colour looks best," we urge you to take a look at our colour comparisons above and below and decide for yourself which camcorder has the best colour. We can tell you that the JVC GC-FM1 had the most accurate colours, but as far as the most pleasing colours—well, that's a matter of personal preference. In the close-ups below you can really see how much the Kodak Zx1's poor white balance affected its image. We should also note that the JVC produced a slightly darker image than the rest of these camcorders, but that is a result of the camcorder's auto exposure system under-exposing the image a bit.

  Close-Up Colour Comparisons
   
  Ideal JVC GC-FM1 Flip UltraHD Sony
MHS-PM1
Kodak Zx1
Red
  Ideal JVC GC-FM1 Flip UltraHD Sony
MHS-PM1
Kodak Zx1
Green
  Ideal JVC GC-FM1 Flip UltraHD Sony
MHS-PM1
Kodak Zx1
Blue
  Ideal JVC GC-FM1 Flip UltraHD Sony
MHS-PM1
Kodak Zx1
Skin
Tone 1
  Ideal JVC GC-FM1 Flip UltraHD Sony
MHS-PM1
Kodak Zx1
Skin
Tone 2

 

Colour Score Comparison the Flip UltraHD Compare the JVC GC-FM1
to the Flip UltraHD
color score comparison chart
the Sony MHS-PM1 Compare the JVC GC-FM1
to the Sony MHS-PM1
the Kodak Zx1 Compare the JVC GC-FM1
to the Kodak Zx1

 

Noise (2.28)


The GC-FM1 didn't have very good noise levels in our bright light testing. The camcorder averaged 1.2775% noise, which is more than double the amount of noise we measured on the Flip UltraHD (it's also more noise than the Sony MHS-PM1 and Kodak Zx1 measured). Interestingly, the GC-FM1 actually measured less noise in our low light testing than in our bright light test. (More on how we test noise.)

Noise Comparisons
JVC GC-FM1
100% Crop
Flip UltraHD
100% Crop
Sony MHS-PM1
100% Crop
Kodak Zx1
100% Crop

You can see some of the noise present in the FM1's image by looking at the crops above. Notice that the Flip UltraHD looks a bit cleaner in comparison. The crops also give you some idea of the sharpness of each camcorder in bright light. The FM1 managed a very sharp image in our bright light testing—sharper than the rest of the ultra-compact camcorders by far.

Noise Score Comparison the Flip UltraHD Compare the JVC GC-FM1
to the Flip UltraHD
noise score comparison chart
the Sony MHS-PM1 Compare the JVC GC-FM1
to the Sony MHS-PM1
the Kodak Zx1 Compare the JVC GC-FM1
to the Kodak Zx1

 



<< Product Tour | Motion & Sharpness Performance >>